Where soft spots appear
On wood subfloors, usually second storeys or pier-and-beam houses, soft spots form around toilets, tubs, showers, dishwashers and water heaters. The plywood or older plank subfloor soaks up repeated small leaks until the layers separate and the wood begins to rot. On a concrete slab the slab itself does not soften, but flooring over it can: laminate swells, and vinyl lifts over a wet patch.
How to check safely
- Look at the flooring around the soft area for staining, lifted seams or gaps in grout.
- Check the ceiling or crawl space underneath for stains, drips or dark wood.
- Push gently; do not jump on it. A floor that is close to failing should not take full weight.
- Notice the smell: rotting wood and mould smell musty and earthy.
What the repair involves
The leak has to be fixed first, often a toilet seal, tub drain or supply line. Then the flooring is removed so the subfloor can be inspected. Wet but solid subfloor can be dried; rotten sections are cut out and replaced, and joists underneath are checked. If the joists are damaged, a carpenter or contractor sisters or replaces them before new subfloor goes down.
A restoration company handles the drying and mould treatment; a remodelling contractor usually handles the rebuild. Some restoration companies do both.
Insurance
Rot from a leak that went on for months is usually treated as wear and tear and excluded. Damage from a sudden failure is more often covered. Either way, photograph the floor before it is opened and keep the plumber's description of what failed.
Common questions
Is it safe to walk on?
Avoid the area and keep heavy furniture off it. A subfloor that has rotted can give way, especially around toilets and tubs where the load is concentrated.
Could it be termites instead of water?
Termites and water damage often go together, because termites like damp wood. If the wood looks hollowed or you see mud tubes, have a pest inspector look as well.
How big a hole will they cut?
Enough to reach solid wood on all sides, usually out to the nearest joists. That is why a small soft spot can turn into a larger repair; the edges have to land on sound framing.
